Garth Marenghi once famously observed that he was the only writer that has written more books than he has read. Obviously now that Russell Brand has written two books the claim is open to challenge but it still raises an interesting question.
To what extent is it desirable to read other works outside one's genre?
Imagine writing an SF novel if all one had ever read was other SF novels. What would the final product be like? My unproven assumption would be that work would be anodyne and unchallenging to the reader. SF is the literature of ideas and those ideas are, on occasion, best mined from outside the genre.
My settled view is that if one is going to learn the craft of writing by reading then learn from the best. If you want the unsurpassed study of psychological disintegration then read Crime and Punishment. If you want to see a perfectly structured novel then reach for The Good Soldier. If you want to experience the benchmark work of magical realism then it's Love in the Time of Cholera you need.
To what extent is it desirable to read other works outside one's genre?
Imagine writing an SF novel if all one had ever read was other SF novels. What would the final product be like? My unproven assumption would be that work would be anodyne and unchallenging to the reader. SF is the literature of ideas and those ideas are, on occasion, best mined from outside the genre.
My settled view is that if one is going to learn the craft of writing by reading then learn from the best. If you want the unsurpassed study of psychological disintegration then read Crime and Punishment. If you want to see a perfectly structured novel then reach for The Good Soldier. If you want to experience the benchmark work of magical realism then it's Love in the Time of Cholera you need.